January 28, 2004

French Military Sales Must Be Down

For Saddam to get captured in his tiny little hole must have really been a blow to Jacques Chirac, as he is now going to push for a lifting of the arms embargo on China.

He claims that the embargo, placed in response to Tiananmen Square, "makes no more sense today."

I guess we really shouldn't be too surprised. Human rights violations are not of great concern to Chirac, unless he can somehow figure out a way to pin them on the United States. He thought that Saddam was fine, and now he is implying that China has reformed its violating ways.

Very little has really changed in China. There are still rampant human rights violations taking place. Look at the current media articles coming out of the region. Remember, this is the country that still has forced population control. But there are certainly no human rights violations taking place....

If Chirac wants to lift the embargo, that's fine. Some things have changed since 1989. Maybe there is a valid reason to lift the embargo (although it would almost certainly intensify the Far Eastern arms race). A debate would not necessarily be a bad thing. But in any discussion, there must still be a recognition and debate about the state of human rights in China. Anything less would be intellectually dishonest.

Chirac seems to be once again demonstrating that he is more interested in selling weapons to whomever, rather than holding true to his rhetoric on human rights.

Posted by Chris at January 28, 2004 10:20 PM | TrackBack | Linked by:

Comments

I don't think selling arms to China is the least bit sane; however, I think it's a little too Western to say it's because of human rights violations. I'd say it's because you don't want one of the craziest parties in the world to have such weapons at its disposal, particularly as it's threatening Taiwan, potentially the Spratly Islands, and others in the region.

Do you want the same folks who covered SARS and now the "bird flu" at the risk of their own population controlling western imported weapons??

On the other hand, if they're from France...

Oh, and the "forced population control" isn't quite as forced as some may think. There are many outs for the average Chinese, though the damage has already been done.

Posted by: undertree at January 29, 2004 02:10 PM


Comments have been closed on this entry in an effort to conserve disk space. If you have feedback on this entry, please email me at blog - at - cbnoble.com.