March 23, 2003
Highly Refined Evil
I’ve been somewhat disturbed by the Russian problems that have come to light today. By the “Russian problems” I mean the sale of GPS jammers to Iraq, the sale of night vision goggles and now the discovery Russian missiles that were produced within the last year. These are all significant problems, but I’ve been unsure how to approach a discussion of the issues.
I’ve been pondering on this for several hours, but during dinner my father called and asked how I thought this affected the humane concerns of this war. In regards to the GPS jammers, he brought up some very interesting points.
He pointed out that most of the bombs we are dropping in Baghdad are JDAM or other GPS guided weapons. We are using these weapons so as to minimize the civilian casualties in the city. With a jammer, the Iraqis would essentially turn our smart bombs into unguided dumb bombs with a corresponding increase in civilian casualties. Since the Iraqi regime doesn’t care about the lives of its citizens, the propaganda value of such misses would be immense.
The misses would also serve to make us doubt the effectiveness of our weapons. There are already reports that just the threat of GPS jammers caused us to slowdown the bombing of Baghdad while we evaluated the effectiveness of the jammers on our weapons.
We have flown thousands of bombing missions over Iraq now; with at last report, 3 civilian deaths. That is absolutely incredible. Never before in history has so much explosive power been used with such a small amount of collateral damage.
The lack of civilian deaths is directly attributable to our use of precision-guided weapons. We have still yet to drop a single dumb bomb. Not one. There is no carpet-bombing this time.
Our foe doesn’t like that. The Iraqis want us to kill civilians. They want to give ammunition to the anti-warriors of the world. Their use of GPS jammers with the intention of deflecting a bomb onto a civilian is proof that we have more concern for their citizens than they do. It is also a crime against humanity (GPS jammers are legit to deflect bombs into unpopulated areas, but not into the heart of a city’s population).
The Russians knew what the intention of the Iraqis was. They knew that the Iraqis would attempt to use these jammers in the commission of crimes against humanity. That tells me that all of the Russian posturing in the UN was a bunch of bunk. They had no concern for the Iraqi citizens – they only had concern for their commercial ties. Putin and Ivanov lied to us. Out and out lied to our faces.
Given their duplicity with the jammers, the NVGs and anti-tank rockets are not a surprise. I also believe that they were at least a legitimate sale in that those tools could really only be used against the US and coalition militaries. I still have a problem with the Russians selling Iraq weapons to use against us while claiming to be our friend, but that is not the same as selling a tool that they knew the Iraqis would use to kill civilians.
In this war, the US has made a concerted effort to bring humanity to the battle. We have gone to extraordinary lengths to protect Iraqi citizens. It is truly a shame to see that our “friends” who had such “concern for human rights” have been selling out the Iraqis human rights. It is a shame that our “friends” have no concern beyond the almighty dollar (or euro or ruble or whatever).
I’m ashamed that I have defended the Russians in the past on this blog. This makes me sick.
Not true! This is Russians trying to make some bucks. This hoax has been going around for months. Slapping it down is like playing whack-a-mole at the fair.
GPS is only one of the guidance systems these weapons use. You can turn GPS off altogether and it will still hit the target within a meter.
Posted by: Donald Sensing at March 23, 2003 08:54 PMInteresting essay. I had discounted the use of INS as a backup guidance system due to the amount of computing power it requires. I know we've got processors smaller and faster, but it's still a lot of computing power to blow up. Learn something new every day.
I'll guess I should also clarify in that I was assuming that the "jammers" being used in this case were not signal blockers, but rather a variation of the GPS transmitters used outside major airports to provide GPS corrections. By using a something similar it would conceivably be possible to draw a bomb off course by simulating a false GPS signal.
This of course would require that when a JDAM ran into a disparity between GPS and INS, it would default to taking the GPS information as gospel.
If a jammer exists that provides a false GPS signal, I would expect that the Russians would have developed one. The fact that we slowed the bombing of the city center in Baghadad tells me that there is a possiblity that such a beast exists.
I hope that you're right and that the Russians pulled off a good con here.
Posted by: Chris at March 23, 2003 09:28 PMComments have been closed on this entry in an effort to conserve disk space. If you have feedback on this entry, please email me at blog - at - cbnoble.com.


